Unfortunately, my nose didn't agree with the P&J version of Grapefruit. I have a grapefruit essential oil (not a fragrance oil) that is closer, and because I was running out of it and I love what I've gotten from P&J so far, I tried it. It seems more flowery than the sweet, sharp tang of grapefruit. P&J did a return for me with no problem, and I was able to try a different scent that I liked better. These are my favorite fragrance oils - so easy to order, easy to return, easy to love! But your nose may be more discerning than mine, so go ahead and try it. You won't be "stuck" with it at P&J! God bless!